picture of several pillows on a bed

Alternative to Buckwheat Pillow: Top 4 Comfortable Substitutes

· 9 min read

Finding the right pillow can significantly impact sleep quality and overall health. Buckwheat pillows are known for their support and breathability, but some may find buckwheat pillows too firm or noisy.

What are some alternatives that can still provide the benefits of natural fill without the drawbacks of buckwheat pillow?

These can range from different fill materials such as down, latex, millet, and memory foam. Each alternative offers unique advantages and catering to varied sleeping preferences.

Several pillows on the bed

Alternative to Buckwheat Pillows

Down Pillows

Down pillows are known for their softness and longevity. Filled with the fine undercoat feathers from ducks or geese, they provide exceptional warmth and can be fluffed to cater to personal comfort preferences.

Latex Pillows

Latex pillows offer resilience paired with firm support. The material's hypoallergenic qualities make it a favorable option for those with allergies. It is also available in both solid and shredded varieties.

Millet Hull Pillows

Millet hull pillows, similar to buckwheat, provide a texture that conforms well to the shape of one's head and neck.

They also promote air circulation, which can result in a cooler sleep surface. Millet hull pillows are typically easier to adjust than their buckwheat counterparts.

Memory Foam Pillows

Memory foam pillows contour closely to the sleeper's body, providing custom support that can help alleviate pressure points.

Often available in contoured shapes, they are particularly beneficial for neck and shoulder support.

Buckwheat Pillow vs. Down Pillow

When comparing the differences between buckwheat pillows and down pillows, one should consider several factors, including support levels, maintenance, and allergenic properties.

Support Levels:

  • Buckwheat Pillows: They offer firm support due to the buckwheat hulls inside, which conform to the shape of the head and neck.
  • Down Pillows: Typically soft and plush, down pillows may not provide as much support as buckwheat, as they tend to sink more under weight.


  • Buckwheat Pillows: These pillows require regular airing out to remove moisture. The hulls may also need replacement over time.
  • Down Pillows: They need to be fluffed regularly to maintain shape and may require professional cleaning to ensure longevity.

Temperature Regulation:

  • Buckwheat Pillows: The space between the hulls allows for air circulation, helping to keep the pillow cool throughout the night.
  • Down Pillows: These can retain heat more due to the dense packing of feathers, potentially leading to a warmer sleep experience.

Allergic Properties:

Table: Allergenic Properties

Pillow TypeAllergen Risk
BuckwheatLow — naturally hypoallergenic; less likely to harbor dust mites.
DownHigher — down is a common allergen and may attract dust mites.

Buckwheat Pillow vs Latex Pillow

When comparing buckwheat pillows to latex pillows, consumers are looking at two distinctly different types of support and comfort.

Buckwheat pillows are filled with hulls from buckwheat seeds, offering a firm and adjustable structure.

Latex pillows, on the other hand, are made from the sap of rubber trees and can either be solid or shredded.

Latex pillows tend to be springy and responsive, providing a softer feel than buckwheat. They are also hypoallergenic and resist dust mites, making them suitable for people with allergies.

Here's a brief comparison:

FeatureBuckwheat PillowLatex Pillow
SupportFirm, adjustableSofter, less adjustable
DurabilityLong-lastingGenerally long-lasting, but can degrade
MaintenanceHulls can be added or removed; occasional airing needed Washable or wipeable, depending on cover
HypoallergenicYes, but hulls can accumulate dust Naturally hypoallergenic and resistant to dust mites
CoolingGood airflow keeps it coolVaries; may retain heat

Buckwheat pillows are renowned for their breathability. Their structure allows air to circulate freely, making them a cooler option. They are generally heavier than latex pillows, and the noise made by the hulls when moving might be bothersome to some.

In contrast, latex pillows offer a silent night's sleep with a bounce-back effect that many find comforting. They are also moldable and can provide a consistently smooth sleep surface.

Depending on the manufacturing process, latex pillows can either have a uniform consistency or a shredded, more adjustable feel.

Buckwheat Pillow vs Millet Pillow

When consumers are faced with choosing between a buckwheat pillow and a millet pillow, they should consider various factors such as firmness, support, and texture.


  • Millet pillows offer a softer feel compared to buckwheat pillow. The hulls inside a millet pillow tend to be smaller and more pliable, conforming more to the shape of the sleeper's head and neck.
  • This can lead to gentler support, which makes millet pillows less firm than buckwheat. Nevertheless, they still support adequate neck alignment.


  • Millet pillows generally retain heat more than buckwheat, potentially making them less suitable for those who sleep hot.


  • Regarding texture, some sleepers may find millet pillows to have a smoother and more velvety touch in contrast to the granular texture of buckwheat. This could influence the decision of someone sensitive to tactile sensations.

Noise level

  • Millet pillows may be quieter compared to buckwheat pillows, making them a better choice for light sleepers who might be disturbed by the sound of shifting hulls.

Buckwheat Pillow vs Memory Foam Pillow

In comparison to buckwheat pillow, memory foam pillows provide even more contour to the shape of the head and neck. This can provide excellent pressure relief.

Memory foam pillows are available in various shapes and densities. They are particularly beneficial for people who have neck pain due to their ability to maintain spinal alignment.

Here are main characteristics of memory foam pillows:

  • Pressure Relief: Excellent
  • Contouring: Yes
  • Heat Retention: Higher
  • Support: Soft to firm, less adjustable

The main differences of these two pillow types are in adjustability and heat retention. Memory foam tends to retain more heat, whereas buckwheat allows for better air circulation.

The buckwheat pillow's adjustability in firmness and shape is superior due to the hulls can move around within the pillow. This is as opposed to the consistent form of memory foam.

However, memory foam's contouring can offer unmatched pressure relief, which for some sleepers, is the deciding factor.

How to Select the Right Pillow for Your Needs

When one is considering alternatives to buckwheat pillows, it is essential to evaluate firmness and support, pillow shape and size, and the understanding of fill power and loft.

Assessing Firmness and Support

The firmness of a pillow contributes significantly to the overall support it provides. A millet pillow can be an adequate choice, offering similar support with a lighter and softer feel.

Considering Pillow Shape and Size

The shape and size of a pillow greatly affect sleeping comfort. It should match one's sleep position and body size to maintain proper alignment.

Traditional rectangular pillows work for most, but other shapes like contour pillows may suit specific needs.

Where to Buy Alternative Pillows

When searching for buying alternatives to buckwheat pillows, consumers have several options ranging from online retailers to specialized bedding stores and eco-friendly marketplaces.

Each offers a different selection and shopping experience to suit individual preferences.

Online Retailers

Consumers can find a diverse range of pillow alternatives through online retailers. Websites like Sleep Foundation often list best organic pillows of the year, providing insight into non-toxic and natural materials.

These e-commerce platforms usually offer detailed product descriptions, customer reviews, and the convenience of home delivery.

Specialty Bedding Stores

Specialty bedding stores are ideal for shoppers who prefer a tangible experience. They can touch and feel different types of pillows, such as organic wool pillows.

They can also receive personalized recommendations from knowledgeable staff. These stores often carry premium products not found in general home goods stores.

Eco-Friendly Marketplaces

For those committed to sustainability, eco-friendly marketplaces offer a curated selection of pillows.

These platforms focus on environmentally conscious products, ensuring that shoppers can purchase pillows that align with their values.



YZ, an engineer with a PhD based in the San Francisco Bay Area, brings practical expertise to Restful Guides. Focused on simple, effective ways to improve sleep and relaxation, YZ offers easy-to-follow advice on choosing the right pillows, bedding, and meditation techniques for a better, more restful life.

Copyright © 2024 RestfulGuides. All rights reserved.
Terms of ServicePrivacy Policy